How to make Britain a nation of YIMBYs

How to make Britain a nation of YIMBYs

By Gil Richards, Researcher at The Future Governance Forum

Britain has an infrastructure problem. We know that we need to build more to boost economic growth, reach net zero, strengthen our national resilience, and raise living standards. And importantly, though perhaps less well recognised, the public wants to see us build more too — two thirds (69%) believe their local community would benefit from more infrastructure.

Yet despite the wide-reaching public and political support for new infrastructure, too many projects face the same fate: they’re slow to deliver, encounter expensive delays, go over budget or fail to deliver the benefits originally promised.

These problems are often blamed on a battle between those who want more of the essential infrastructure we all need, and those who stand in the way. But this is far too simplistic.

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support our work.

To understand the problem, we need to look at the current blueprint for getting things built in Britain. This, by and large, follows the same script: politicians in Westminster set national priorities, regional leaders are informed of those plans and asked to support the delivery of them (if they are consulted at all), and communities are invited to comment once major decisions have been made. In short, most communities experience infrastructure as something done to them, rather than done with them.

So how do we change this?

Today we’re launching a new report — A Mandate to Build: A new approach to public engagement in infrastructure planning — with the Institution of Civil Engineers exploring what a better approach to infrastructure delivery could look like: one that involves communities and regional leaders in the right place, at the right time.

We argue that government doesn’t need to choose between pace and participation. In reality, most people don’t want to stop infrastructure projects; they want to shape them. Allowing them to do so could lead to fewer delays, smoother delivery and cheaper project costs — all while boosting public trust.

To achieve this, our report outlines four ways to improve engagement:

  1. Ensure it happens at the right time by giving citizens an opportunity to shape national strategy. Each refresh of the 10-Year Infrastructure Strategy should be informed by a representative citizens’ process commissioned by the National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority (NISTA).

  2. Ensure it happens in the right place by giving mayors and strategic authorities a role in infrastructure planning. Spatial Development Strategies should guide decisions on where and how nationally significant infrastructure is delivered, with mayors given powers to consent to and shape regional projects.

  3. Make it clearer and easier to engage with by introducing an early, independent assessment of the key issues facing infrastructure projects and making clear during public consultation what is fixed and what is open for discussion.

  4. Let communities feel the benefit of local infrastructure by establishing a new Strategic Infrastructure Community Fund to ensure infrastructure meets local needs, rather than simply compensating communities for any harms caused.

By strengthening local engagement in the right place, at the right time, the Prime Minister has an opportunity to connect infrastructure delivery to his wider political ambitions: spurring regional growth, strengthening public control, and restoring faith that Britain is a country that can build things at scale again.

Read the report

Sign up to our newsletter

TEMPLogoAsset-2

Keep up to date with our work

Your email address is never shared with any third parties. You will only receive updates from Future Governance Forum about our work.